Monday, 16 January 2017

The weather is not the climate: predicting the economic impacts of Brexit

Interviewed for ITN/Channel 4 News, I was asked – very reasonably – why anyone should listen to economists’ views on the economic impacts of Brexit, when many short-term forecasts that a Brexit vote would lead to a sharp slowing of the economy had been proved wrong.  This was my response: 
“Short-term economic forecasting is very unreliable. Just because the weatherman gets it wrong about whether it’s going to snow tomorrow doesn’t mean that the scientists have it wrong about whether climate change is going to make the planet warmer over the medium to long term”
I think it’s worth explaining this.  The forecasters – including City economists and independent research institutions like NIESR and IFS, as well as the Treasury and the IMF - who predicted economic gloom as a direct result, not of Brexit itself but of the referendum result, did so on the basis of the expected impact on financial markets, business and consumer confidence:  “Our research shows that a vote to leave would increase uncertainty and, at best, reduce growth”.  

But they were (mostly) wrong.  On the markets, while the pound did indeed fall much as expected (which is actually good for economic activity in the short-term; the exchange rate acts a shock absorber to the expected long term hit to the economy by making UK exports cheaper) market interest rates didn’t rise and the stock market didn’t collapse (although UK companies have certainly underperformed). More importantly, after an initial shock to confidence, businesses and consumers appear to have decided that nothing has happened yet and nothing much will happen for a while; so it’s business as usual. Research on uncertainty, it turns out, isn’t exactly a certainty.

We can dismiss a couple of excuses for this failure. It’s true Brexit hasn’t happened yet – but the forecasts were explicitly related not to Brexit, but to the uncertainty and expected future impact of Brexit.  It’s true some (but not all) of the forecasts assumed immediate Article 50 notification, but that was not central – and if it was uncertainty that was supposed to drive economic weakness, delaying notification merely prolongs the uncertainty.  And it's true there was a policy response from the  Bank of England - but if anything could have been forecasted it was that.

So what forecasters fundamentally got wrong was their judgement about the short-term behaviour of millions of individuals interacting in a very complex system, where (as we know from the analysis of such systems) relatively small changes in a few variables can lead to quite different outcomes.  The claim that “the flap of a butterfly’s wing in Brazil can set off a tornado in Texas” is poetic license – but the inherent difficulty of forecasting short to medium term perturbations is true both of the economy and the weather.  

Now, despite these difficulties, weather forecasting has got considerably more reliable over the last 20 years, so there’s plenty of room for economic forecasters to improve – but  explaining how the economy will do in the next few months is always likely to be very challenging. That’s true of economic forecasting in “normal” times: but it’s even more so the case when trying to assess the short-term impacts of a political event on the psychological attitudes of consumers and investors.

By contrast, predictions about the long-term impact of Brexit – like climate science  - are based on quite different reasoning, about how changing one key factor – our openness to trade, or the degree to which the earth’s atmosphere retains heat – changes the long-run properties of the system.  The methodologies used are well-established and robust – and while of course the detailed modelling of their impacts requires considerable expertise and huge amounts of data, the basic mechanisms at work are well-established and easy enough to explain.  The operation of the greenhouse effect can be demonstrated in a school lab.

Similarly, the basic insights of the “gravity model” approach to predicting international trade – that trade between two economies depends on how big each is, how far apart they are, and historical, cultural and policy factors including the existence of special trade arrangements like the EU – are common sense, and their empirical and practical validity is not seriously in question.  More CO2 will make us hotter: less trade and migration will make us poorer.  

Now, economists’ forecasts of the long-term impacts of Brexit could still be wrong – or inaccurate- just as climate scientists could be wrong about the path of climate change. First, our scenarios could be wrong; Brexit could turn out very differently from the options (hard or soft, clean or chaotic) most people are trying to analyse; similarly, sudden technological advances could change the path of CO2 emissions.  Second, the numbers are probably more uncertain even more than the models (which already incorporate some forms of uncertainty) suggest – some forms of uncertainty are simply impossible to model.

So while we can predict that Brexit will reduce growth and CO2 will warm the planet, we should take the quantitative modelling on just how large these effects are with a large pinch of salt.  In particular, feedback effects could either amplify or dampen the impacts – and it is very difficult to guess which. But the basic point - that reductions in trade and migration will reduce growth and productivity, relative to what otherwise would have occurred – is very unlikely to be disproved, any more than the greenhouse effect.

So how should that translate into how we actually make decisions?  Well, I listen to the weather forecast: but, like most Londoners, whatever it says, I always carry an umbrella.  On the other hand, that doesn’t mean I’d buy a house on a flood plain. 

27 comments:

  1. Interesting and thoughtful post.

    Other areas in which economists could be wrong about the long-term consequences are:
    1) Underestimating the benefits (could be cost, but more likely benefits) of moving much regulatory and virtually all agricultural policy to a national level, which will probably tend to a more liberal direction than at an EU level. Prior to the referendum most economists accorded little or no weight to this.
    2) a) Underestimating the speed and extent to which the UK completes FTAs with 3rd parties (again, they could be wrong in the other direction too; but given the conservative assumptions in this area of most pre-referendum forecasts, it is more likely that UK will perform on the upside. And political developments in the US have been an early boost to the UK) b) They may also have underestimated the benefits of trade diversification: that is to say, even if the net effect of freer trade beyond the EU and less free trade within the EU was neutral, the indirect effects on competition/ innovation may be net positive by being more exposed to different economies with which the UK currently trades little, whilst still trading a lot (but less than present) with the EU
    3) There being galvanising effects of the referendum on intangibles: UK companies spurred to seek out new markets; UK consumers more confident about their long-term prospects now that finally the elites have listened to them; and overseas consumers more aware of and positive about the UK brand (research show an overall positive impact on the UK’s international reputation so far, in most geographies outside Europe itself); also, arguably a government which will be more single minded in pursuing pro-growth policies
    4) A shock in the EU (e.g. eurozone implosion) which generally weren’t included in the counterfactuals – clearly this would hit the UK in or out of the EU, but exposure would be greater if in
    None of these would contradict the argument of the post that open trade and migration are good for an economy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. All these points are potentially true - although equally as you recognise both 1) and 3) could go in the other direction (it's far from obvious we will pursue more liberal policies outside the EU..). On 2, see my former NIESR colleague Monique Ebell's work.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Personally I struggle with the Brexit analysis that trade with rest of the world was significantly restrained by being part of EU. There is no iota of evidence for this looking at Germany's exporting prowess. In trade terms I think we are being guided by people who finding their boat is sinking in the harbour, decide to leave the harbour. The comment above ignores the fact that nearly all the EU animal welfare and environmental legislation was driven by Whitehall. We were using the EU to stop our nearest and dearest neighbours from competing with UK farmers on an unfair playing field. Brexit will stop us stopping them (if you follow the logic), but I doubt it will stop Whitehall imposing rules on UK farmers. UK Farming needed Whitehall exit not EU Exit. Our economic performance has been better than expected post Brexit, but we will see this is uncharted territory and it misses the point which is "how much better would our performance have been had we not voted Brexit"? What psychologists call the "confirmation bias" has resulted in people going into silos where they talk only to each other about things that confirm their prejudices. I include myself in that. Brexit has been better than I feared ... but pointing to businesses investing in the UK only proves Brexit did not stop them, it does not show who else has gone elsewhere.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not sure what your struggle is. The EU has a Customs Union which has a CET and other barriers to trade with those outside it. Germany does relatively well at trade - so what? That is of no relevance to the question of whether countries would trade more with non-EU countries if not part of the CU. The net effect of being out of the CU (negative impact on intra-CU trade but positive upside beyond) is highly debateable of course. For a country like the U.K., with a minority and declining share of trade with EU countries and a mindset which is more pro-free trade than the average EU member, it is more likely to be positive than for most others.

      Delete
  4. Prof Portes
    I agree with what you have written. Short term forecasting is essentially a mug's game - but cannot be avoided. The bigger issue is that some (e.g. Economists for BREXIT) argue the models used by many to think about the long term / structural effects of BREXIT are wrong. For example, my reading of a 13 July 2016 PowerPoint presentation of Economists for BREXIT is that they even reject even the gravity trade model. To use your analogy, those favouring BREXIT appear to argue that the UK has already bought a house on a flood plain (membership of the EU). Therefore the UK must sell up and relocate.

    Ian Bright

    ReplyDelete
  5. Child Models Wanted Urgently-No Experience Required
    Apply Now to Become a Model. Free Training and Coaching. Free Pro Photo, We can advise and help your child to become a child model.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have to say I find this whole argument a bit of a stretch. The comparison of economic forecasting with climate science seems intended to lend credibility to the former which it does not deserve. I find the idea, based on the comparison with climate science, that short term forecasting is difficult and longterm forecasting more reliable hard to swallow. If economists were so good at predicting the economy in the long or medium term, then presumably they'd all be rich. The comparison with weather/climate does not work.
    You make the comparison with a weather forecast of snow tomorrow. Where the weather forecaster's prediction usually goes wrong is where and when it will snow. So if it does not snow on my house at the predicted time, I regard the forecast as wrong. It probably did snow, but they got the timing or location wrong.
    Long term economic forecasting is not like climate change. Scientist may argue about how fast global temperatures will rise, but there is consensus that they will and the causes. Apart from the planet being struck by an asteroid there are few totally unpredictable factors. Though of course more science leads to more information. For long term economic forecasts however there are a huge number of unpredictable factors.
    What happens, for example, if North Korea fires off a nuclear rocket? Or the USA invades North Korea to prevent them from doing this? There are endless unpredictable possibilities.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great knowledge, do anyone mind merely reference back to it
    brexitapp

    ReplyDelete
  8. I got my already programmed blank ATM card to withdraw a maximum of $5,000 daily for 30 days. I am so happy about this because i got mine last week and I have used it to get $100,000. Mrs OMON is giving out the card just to help the poor and needy though it is illegal but it is something nice and she is not like other scam pretending to have the blank ATM cards. And no one gets caught when using the card. get yours from her. Just send her an email on: atmmachine581@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. MY HERPES RESULT..Hi everyone, well it's been about 9 months since my first outbreak! Finally starting to feel like myself again! I just never in a millions years thought this could happen to me, i thought it was all a joke when i notice, i am very lucky that i even gave this doctor herbal medicine a try, i am really feeling healthy and strong without outbreak, so i was wondering if i am still herpes positive then i went for check up today i was confirm negative, i am so shock about my result today, people say's there is no cure how come i was cure with herbal medicine, i still imagine if i was dreaming, the last two years i tested positive i almost committed suicide thank God now i am alive and healthy, i don't want to experience this good luck alone of been cure so i have to share this doctor email so people who have herpes can contact him. he is 100% real and trusted herbalcure12@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  10. MY HERPES RESULT..Hi everyone, well it's been about 9 months since my first outbreak! Finally starting to feel like myself again! I just never in a millions years thought this could happen to me, i thought it was all a joke when i notice, i am very lucky that i even gave this doctor herbal medicine a try, i am really feeling healthy and strong without outbreak, so i was wondering if i am still herpes positive then i went for check up today i was confirm negative, i am so shock about my result today, people say's there is no cure how come i was cure with herbal medicine, i still imagine if i was dreaming, the last two years i tested positive i almost committed suicide thank God now i am alive and healthy, i don't want to experience this good luck alone of been cure so i have to share this doctor email so people who have herpes can contact him. he is 100% real and trusted herbalcure12@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  11. WORRY NO MORE ON HERPES VIRUS!!! THE CURE YOU NEED IS HERE NOW!!!

    Good News My People .. Am Mrs Mia Milavic from Croatia but based in USA. I Want To Appreciate Dr Oboh Hakuna Herbal Medicine Is A Good Herbal Medicine For ( HERPES VIRUS ) I Was Diagnosed With HERPES Virus Last Month, And I Was Looking For Solution To Be Cure Luckily I Saw A Testimonies On How Dr Oboh Hakuna Cure HERPES VIRUS I Decided To Contact Dr Oboh Hakuna, as I Contacted Him (obohsolutionhome@gmail.com) He Prepared A Herbal Medicine Portion And Sent It To Me,I Started The Herbal Medicine For My Health.He Gave Me Step By Step Instructions On How To Apply It, When I Applied It As Instructed, I Was Cured Of This Deadly Herpes Virus Within 2weeks, I Am Now HERPES Negative. My Brothers And Sisters I know That There Are So Many People That Have The Same Herpes Virus Please go to Dr Oboh Hakuna to Help You too, And Help Me To Thank Dr Oboh Hakuna For Curing Me, I’m Cured By Dr Oboh Hakuna Herbal Medicine, His Contact Or Cell Whatsapp Number (+2348132062163)
    contact Dr Oboh on this email at (obohsolutionhome@gmail.com) i tell you that you will be free from herpes virus as i am free from it today!!

    you can also reach me on my email at (mrsmiamilavic@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Good day to all the viewers.I'm from England U K. I’m indeed very happy for the great work Dr. IyaryI done for I and my husband was a HERPES GENITAL PATIENT and i contact herpes true my husband also me i was a herpes patient, and ever since were living with it ,taking medications till faithful day when I met a close friend she brief me what she saw on a blog about how Dr IyaryI herbal medicine cured Herpes patient,so one faithful day when I went online, I met plenty of testimonials about this great man called Dr IyaryI how he cure manner of herpes disease, so I decided to give it a try and to God be the glory he did. he cured me and my husband illness and I am so very happy and so happy to write about it today.and asked us to go for check-up after 2 weeks,Luckily the doctor told us we were tested herpes negative, now I believe all these Testimonies about him on the Internet,is not a scam he is truly a great man, all thank to you Dr. IyaryI for cured me and my husband we owe you in return,my view friend please Dr IyaryI help them and God will increase you! thanks you again Dr IyaryI for putting a smile on my face again so i am posting to this forum saying if you are into similar situation or have any kind of disease problem you can contact him to help you: contact him through his email driayaryi2012@hotmail.com. Or you can contact him on WhatsApp +2349057915709

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hi Viewers, My husband was diagnosed officially in January of 2010 but had symptoms for two years prior to that. We are blessed in that he has a slow moving case and so far has affected his arms And legs. Now he has also develop slurred speech. What I did not expect though is that over the last 7+ years, ALS has slowly killed our marriage. The disease has changed him physically and mentally. Now we are not connected. We just continue to soldier on for the sake of the kids who are 14, 12, and 9. He cannot work so I work full time. The stress and responsibility I feel sometimes is overwhelming. I truly believe he does not love me anymore. And if it weren't for the ALS, we would probably separate. I feel very grief stricken over the death of our marriage. I desperately search for an alternative cure to save my marriage till a friend of mine from UK told me about Dr. Godsent Yare who cured her husband from ALS, PLS, FSHD with HIs Herbal Healing Oil and Root/Herbs. I contacted Dr. Yare through His what's app number and told him about my husband ALS problem and he assured me that my husband will be cure. I bought His cure for my husband and he sent it through a courier delivery service to my address which I sent to him. I received it within 4 days and my husband immediately commerce usage as prescribed and was totally cured of ALS within two months. You can contact Dr Yare Mohamend via his email: drmohamendherbalremedy@gmail.com or call/whatsapp on +2348148010628. This great man has save my husband and also save my marriage. My husband is completely free from this disease and now loved me more then ever. Thank you Dr. Yare Mohamend for the help. I promise to share your awesome herbal cure with friends and family.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi Everyone! My name is CHERRYSHANE. I was diagnosed with HERPES 2 in April of 2012 when I was 24 years old who just completed my MA in sociology at the University of Northern Colorado where I explored the role of stigma in the process of disclosing a genital herpes diagnosis.I have wanted to get this virus cured, I am happy to share that with you! few weeks ago i came on search on the INTERNET if i could get any information concerning the prevention of this disease, on my search i saw a testimony of someone who has been healed from (Hepatitis B and Cancer) by this Man Dr ERO and she also gave the email address (eromosalespelltemple@gmail.com) and advise we should contact him for any sickness that he would be of help so i told my husband about it the he ask me to write him because this pain has been constant especially in my knees. so i wrote to Dr ERO telling him about my (HERPES Virus) he told me not to worry that it was going to be cured!! then i took the medicine he sent me, which few weeks later i started experiencing changes all over me as the Dr assured me that i have cured hence i have taken the medicine and then after some time i went to my doctor to confirmed if i have be finally healed behold it was TRUE. I can understand that lots of people are been diagnosed with this same virus so am excited to be able to share some of my experiences and thoughts about this man that you can as well contact him for help living with genital herpes is not a good thing..HERE ARE HIS CONTACT: EMAIL : (eromosalespelltemple@gmail.com) OR YOU CAN AS WELL VISIT HIS his website http://eromosalspiritualtemple.webs.com BETTER STILL CALL OR whats-app HIM via+2348161850195..GOD BLESS

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hello everyone, this is serious. I am happy to share this miraculous testimony about my dad, My Dad of 68 years who has suffered of HERPES for 1 and half years has been cured by a Herbal doctor called Dr. WILLIAM who uses herbal and traditional medicine to cure people. I have spent so much on my Dad’s health paying hospital bills for years but no improvement. A friend told me about this herbal man who cure people with herbal medicine. He cures all sickness, diseases, viruses, and infections with his different herbal curing medicine. He is blessed by God to save man with his herbal medicine; he is true and would not take much to cure you.
    The result that declares my Dad Roland healed was from a hospital here in New York, And the results of the test says my Dad was okay. Dr WILLIAM directed that Dad would be okay in 21 days if she uses the medicine as directed. And 21 days later, we went to confirm it from the central hospital and several tests that was done says my Dad is fully healed. So she was cured by this herbal doctor in 21 days. These amaze me though. I would advise everyone to meet this Dr WILLIAM who made my Dad healthy again.
    Meet Dr WILLIAM and set yourself and your love ones free.
    Doctor WILLIAMS email again is…. DRWILLIAMOBOHSPELLHOME@GMAIL.COM
    you can also contact him via his FACEBOOK PAGE..FOLLOW THIS LINK….https://web.facebook.com/DrWilliam-Herbal-Healing-Home-156277961591731/
    call or whats app………………. +2347065237363

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi Everyone
    My mind, for some reason, wont let go of my memory's of My Wife. I had a very big problem with my wife few months ago, that lead to her leaving me. All efforts to get her back proved abortive. one day while going through the internet i saw so many testimony of this great man called Dr.Goodluck and how he helped people with all kinds of problem, his advert was everywhere,. Although I never believed in spell casting, but I had no choice than to give him a try so i contacted Him, I was so desperate to have my wife back with me once again. So I did all he told me to do. He told me thatmy wife will come back to me in the next 17hours after the spell is completed. I was skeptical. He casted the spell for me and i was so anxious waiting to see or hear from her, it was just 14hours after the spell was done my wife called and said she was coming HOME and she was asking for forgiveness for her ever hurting me before…..It was a dream come through for me!!! that was how my family and relationship was save and our relationship is now stronger than ever.my advice to you out there facing same problem or even worst then mine cry no more and contact this great man called Dr Goodluck He's capable of handling any kind of problem.
    Contact him with his Email him at: goodluck05spellcaster@gmail.com
    Call or Whats-app him: +2348138654465
    website http://drgoodluck.simplesite.com or http://lovespelltogetyourexback.weebly.com

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hello all viewer online herpes has cure but doctor said herpes has no cure until i met Dr PETER who help me in my life. I was infected with Herpes Genital in 2008, i went to many hospitals for cure but there was no solution, so I was thinking how can I get a solution, so that my body can be okay. until this faithful day as i was browsing the net I saw a testimony on how Dr. PETER helped people in curing HERPES disease, quickly I copied his Email which is Dr.Peterspelltemple@gmail.com so i contacted him for solution for my Herpes, so Dr PETER told me that his going to prepare herbal medicine for my health,then he prepared the medicine and luckily after two week my herpes was be cured. Dr PETER is well recognize as one of the best herbalist doctor in Africa, you don't have to be sad anymore or share your tears anymore on this disease when the cure have already be found by Dr. PETER herbal medicine, he so cure HIV,CANCER, ALS,HEPATITIS B, DIABETIC ,Email him today on Dr.Peterspelltemple@gmail.com or whatsapp him now on +2348065331495 A very big thanks to you Dr PETER once again

    ReplyDelete
  18. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!
    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
    Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: micheallee002@outlook.com
    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS.
    you order for:: via micheallee002@outlook.com

    Here is our price list for ATM cards:


    Cards that withdraw $5,500 per day costs $200 USD

    Cards that withdraw $10,000 per day costs $355 USD

    Cards that withdraw $35,000 per day costs $550 USD

    Cards that withdraw $50,000 per day costs $3670 USD

    Cards that withdraw $100,000 per day costs $5600 USD
    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address::micheallee002@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete
  19. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!
    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
    Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: micheallee002@outlook.com
    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS.
    you order for:: via micheallee002@outlook.com

    Here is our price list for ATM cards:


    Cards that withdraw $5,500 per day costs $200 USD

    Cards that withdraw $10,000 per day costs $355 USD

    Cards that withdraw $35,000 per day costs $550 USD

    Cards that withdraw $50,000 per day costs $3670 USD

    Cards that withdraw $100,000 per day costs $5600 USD
    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address::micheallee002@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete
  20. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!
    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
    Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: micheallee002@outlook.com
    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS.
    you order for:: via micheallee002@outlook.com

    Here is our price list for ATM cards:


    Cards that withdraw $5,500 per day costs $200 USD

    Cards that withdraw $10,000 per day costs $355 USD

    Cards that withdraw $35,000 per day costs $550 USD

    Cards that withdraw $50,000 per day costs $3670 USD

    Cards that withdraw $100,000 per day costs $5600 USD
    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address::micheallee002@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete
  21. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!
    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
    Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: micheallee002@outlook.com
    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS.
    you order for:: via micheallee002@outlook.com

    Here is our price list for ATM cards:


    Cards that withdraw $5,500 per day costs $200 USD

    Cards that withdraw $10,000 per day costs $355 USD

    Cards that withdraw $35,000 per day costs $550 USD

    Cards that withdraw $50,000 per day costs $3670 USD

    Cards that withdraw $100,000 per day costs $5600 USD
    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address::micheallee002@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete
  22. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!
    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
    Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: micheallee002@outlook.com
    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS.
    you order for:: via micheallee002@outlook.com

    Here is our price list for ATM cards:


    Cards that withdraw $5,500 per day costs $200 USD

    Cards that withdraw $10,000 per day costs $355 USD

    Cards that withdraw $35,000 per day costs $550 USD

    Cards that withdraw $50,000 per day costs $3670 USD

    Cards that withdraw $100,000 per day costs $5600 USD
    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address::micheallee002@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete
  23. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!
    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
    Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: micheallee002@outlook.com
    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS.
    you order for:: via micheallee002@outlook.com

    Here is our price list for ATM cards:


    Cards that withdraw $5,500 per day costs $200 USD

    Cards that withdraw $10,000 per day costs $355 USD

    Cards that withdraw $35,000 per day costs $550 USD

    Cards that withdraw $50,000 per day costs $3670 USD

    Cards that withdraw $100,000 per day costs $5600 USD
    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address::micheallee002@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete
  24. Get rich today and take the risk of transforming your own life.Try and
    get an ATM card blank today (MR ANDERSON) and be among the lucky ones who are benefiting from this card. This ATM card in white set is capable of hacking into any ATM anywhere in the world. I have to know about this ATM card when I was Searching for job online about a month ago..It has really changed my life forever and now I can say I'm rich because I am a living testimony. The less money I get in a day with this card is $ 3,000.Every now and then money keep pumping into my account. Although illegal, it is programmed so that it can not track, but also has a technique that makes it impossible for the CCTV to detect you..For details on how to get yours today, email hackers;unlimitedhackersworld@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete


  25. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!
    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
    Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: micheallee002@outlook.com
    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS.
    you order for::micheallee002@outlook.com

    Here is our price list for ATM cards:
    BALANCE PRICE
    $5,000----------------$300
    $10,000 ------------- $650
    $20,000 ------------- $1,200
    $35,000 --------------$1,900
    $50,000 ------------- $2,700
    $100,000------------- $5,200

    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address::micheallee002@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete


  26. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!
    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
    Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: micheallee002@outlook.com
    We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS.
    you order for::micheallee002@outlook.com

    Here is our price list for ATM cards:
    BALANCE PRICE
    $5,000----------------$300
    $10,000 ------------- $650
    $20,000 ------------- $1,200
    $35,000 --------------$1,900
    $50,000 ------------- $2,700
    $100,000------------- $5,200

    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address::micheallee002@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete